Harrow Council has disclosed that almost £3.7 million has been paid from its insurance fund since 2022. The disclosure raises a serious question for ratepayers: how much is Harrow actually paying when council decisions, actions and services go wrong?
The figure emerged from a Freedom of Information request made by Harrow Monitoring Group following its earlier article, Harrow’s cost of getting it wrong: who is advising the council when taxpayers keep picking up the bill? Crucially, the council says the £3.7 million relates only to information held by its Insurance Team and does not represent the full cost of compensation, settlements, legal costs, Ombudsman remedies or adverse legal proceedings recorded elsewhere.
That qualification may be more important than the headline figure itself. Harrow says information held by its Legal Team is not maintained in a reportable format, raising questions about how senior management and elected members obtain a comprehensive picture of financial exposure, identify recurring risks and learn from previous decisions.
The importance of preventive governance becomes clearer when considered against Harrow’s wider financial-control environment. The council’s Annual Governance Statement recorded an unresolved governance issue involving allegations of fraud and corruption, a police investigation and further audit work producing only “Limited Assurance”. Although entirely separate from the compensation and legal claims discussed here, this reinforces the importance of effective financial safeguards, early risk identification and corporate oversight.
HMG’s earlier examination also highlighted Harrow’s refusal to permit the felling of two protected trees following a subsidence claim. The council subsequently settled the statutory compensation claim for £30,000 and unsuccessfully contested the insurer’s entitlement to legal costs before the Upper Tribunal. Other examples included pothole and pavement claims, Housing Ombudsman maladministration findings and failures affecting children and SEND services. These are different matters and do not necessarily demonstrate poor decision-making, but they justify scrutiny of the arrangements intended to prevent avoidable financial loss.
Such expenditure also places the quality and use of legal advice under legitimate scrutiny. Although compensation payments do not themselves establish that legal advice was defective, ratepayers are entitled to expect rigorous assessment of legal risks, prospects of success, proportionality and financial exposure, alongside effective challenge by the senior officers and elected members responsible for decisions.
The FOI therefore leaves an important accountability gap. Harrow should be able to demonstrate how the cumulative financial consequences are monitored, reported, analysed for recurring causes and used to improve professional practice and decision-making. The test is whether the council can distinguish unavoidable expenditure from potentially preventable costs and demonstrate that lessons have reduced the likelihood of recurrence.
Ultimately, when ratepayers keep picking up the bill, who is testing the quality of legal advice, who is challenging the decisions, who is assessing the effectiveness and accountability of those responsible, and who is ensuring that avoidable mistakes do not cost the public again?
The figure emerged from a Freedom of Information request made by Harrow Monitoring Group following its earlier article, Harrow’s cost of getting it wrong: who is advising the council when taxpayers keep picking up the bill? Crucially, the council says the £3.7 million relates only to information held by its Insurance Team and does not represent the full cost of compensation, settlements, legal costs, Ombudsman remedies or adverse legal proceedings recorded elsewhere.
That qualification may be more important than the headline figure itself. Harrow says information held by its Legal Team is not maintained in a reportable format, raising questions about how senior management and elected members obtain a comprehensive picture of financial exposure, identify recurring risks and learn from previous decisions.
The importance of preventive governance becomes clearer when considered against Harrow’s wider financial-control environment. The council’s Annual Governance Statement recorded an unresolved governance issue involving allegations of fraud and corruption, a police investigation and further audit work producing only “Limited Assurance”. Although entirely separate from the compensation and legal claims discussed here, this reinforces the importance of effective financial safeguards, early risk identification and corporate oversight.
HMG’s earlier examination also highlighted Harrow’s refusal to permit the felling of two protected trees following a subsidence claim. The council subsequently settled the statutory compensation claim for £30,000 and unsuccessfully contested the insurer’s entitlement to legal costs before the Upper Tribunal. Other examples included pothole and pavement claims, Housing Ombudsman maladministration findings and failures affecting children and SEND services. These are different matters and do not necessarily demonstrate poor decision-making, but they justify scrutiny of the arrangements intended to prevent avoidable financial loss.
Such expenditure also places the quality and use of legal advice under legitimate scrutiny. Although compensation payments do not themselves establish that legal advice was defective, ratepayers are entitled to expect rigorous assessment of legal risks, prospects of success, proportionality and financial exposure, alongside effective challenge by the senior officers and elected members responsible for decisions.
The FOI therefore leaves an important accountability gap. Harrow should be able to demonstrate how the cumulative financial consequences are monitored, reported, analysed for recurring causes and used to improve professional practice and decision-making. The test is whether the council can distinguish unavoidable expenditure from potentially preventable costs and demonstrate that lessons have reduced the likelihood of recurrence.
Ultimately, when ratepayers keep picking up the bill, who is testing the quality of legal advice, who is challenging the decisions, who is assessing the effectiveness and accountability of those responsible, and who is ensuring that avoidable mistakes do not cost the public again?
Harrow’s cost of getting it wrong: who is advising the council when taxpayers keep picking up the bill?
Freedom of Information response
